democracy – dead or alive?
Post on Dec.11, 2007
anyone of you catch the commentary by our very own PM at the wall street journal on 7 dec? "malaysia’s democracy is strong" he said. makes me laugh. i suppose he was very confident to say this after the new global survey, Voice of the People, conducted by TNS and gallup international. see jeff’s post about the survey. now i’ll let you read what our dear PM boasted about.
(note: do scroll down for a very nice cartoon on democracy, ok)
———-
Malaysia’s Democracy Is Strong
COMMENTARY By ABDULLAH AHMAD BADAWI
This year, Malaysia celebrated its 50th anniversary of independence, what we Malaysians term "merdeka. " In this short period, we have achieved much as a nation. Poverty has been reduced tenfold, a thriving middle class created, and the foundations for a competitive 21st century economy put in place. But our most striking accomplishment is that we have managed all this while maintaining harmony within an ethnically diverse society.
In recent weeks, however, a series of public rallies have attracted international attention, leading some to question our nation’s commitment to democratic freedoms. As Prime Minister and as a Malaysian, I am proud of our nation’s democratic heritage and our continuing respect for free speech, pluralism and fair elections.
Many of the protestors are demanding democratic reforms. All democracies can, of course, be improved upon. That is why our electoral commission recently announced that at the next election, transparent voting boxes will replace the traditional black boxes, indelible ink will be introduced, and observers of all major political parties will be allowed to monitor voting in military bases. The electoral commission is also taking a number of other steps, including updating the voter database.
In all democracies, the right to protest is fundamental, but it is a right that must be matched by a responsibility to respect general public safety. Malaysian law stipulates that marches or rallies must be agreed with the police in advance. If protestors have not sought authorization, then the police are bound by duty to enforce the law and ensure public safety. In exercising this duty, the police must balance the protestors’ rights with the safety and security of normal Malaysians. This is not always an easy balance to strike.
In all multicultural societies, tensions will inevitably surface; Malaysia is no exception. Our common challenge is to ensure that our response to the concerns and grievances of our fellow citizens is compassionate, measured, fair and respectful of the rule of law. In return, we ask that those with grievances display a similar degree of respect and consideration to the government and the society at large.
In this vein, I welcome the recent decision of the Malaysian Bar Council to cancel their planned march on Sunday. But there are others who are far more opportunistic and irresponsible. In the case of two recent demonstrations, the Malaysian police had offered the chance for the organizers to hold their protests in stadiums or other alternative venues. Instead, they chose to take to the streets, disrupting people’s lives and putting themselves and others in harm’s way.
As Prime Minister I am willing to listen to all points of view and concerns that are honestly and reasonably presented. However, we cannot and shall not tolerate those who seek to incite or provoke violence for their own personal gain.
How we address the challenges that have arisen today, in our 50th anniversary of independence, will not only determine the economic future of our great nation, but will become the bedrock that defines our character for generations to come. It is my sincere hope that in Malaysia’s 100th anniversary year, our heirs can be proud that reason, moderation and, most importantly, democracy prevailed. If so, the combination of political stability and our rich cultural and ethnic diversity will ensure that our continuing high levels of economic growth can provide new opportunities for all. This is a goal around which all Malaysians can unite.
Mr. Abdullah is Prime Minister of Malaysia.
online WSJ
———————————————————
here’s a ‘telling’ (our country?) cartoon taken from the eight day for you to enjoy.
















December 11th, 2007 on 5:13 am
Democrazy? Ya! Democracy is DEAD! It’s now Totalitarianism.
December 11th, 2007 on 7:25 am
It’s actually the Pretense that just finally died.
December 11th, 2007 on 9:31 am
lucia, that cartoon is BRILLIANT hahahahaha!!
December 11th, 2007 on 10:55 am
Someone (and I can’t recall who now) noted that the survey was carried out well before the Batu Burok riot, and therefore would reflect the sentiments then. Then again 1,000+ aren’t necessarily representative of the entire nation – it was noted that the survey respondents were from undisclosed urban areas.
But to your question: Democracy is life-suipport, and the vital signs are fading…
December 11th, 2007 on 12:00 pm
Dear Lulu,
I have always seen you in Susan Loone’s blog. Your lil’ cartoon depicts the Americans as asserting thier democracy over the world that infers “that if you are not adopting our style and standards of democracy, we will tear you down and impose our democracy on you”.
The justifications of the American in going to war on Iraq was the sketchy ‘weapons-of-mass-destruction’ President Bush and his reliable advisors, VP Dick Cheney, and then hawkish Donad Rumsfeld presumed Saddam of hiding and the perilious such weapons posed on thier neighbours esp. Isreal, in retrospect, Saddam readily uses against anyone even it’s citizens.
Although the arsenal of what President Bush referred to as “WMD” was never founded, speaking about democracy, has not the people of Iraq being liberated of the ‘democracy’ Saddam imposed on them by proclaiming of winning 100% of the votes. Then during the American incursions, have one not seen on CNN that why would many Iraqis esp. of Shiite ethnicity tore, mocked and pissed of the statues and other emblems of Saddam? Have they lost their way to the polling station?
I have mixed feeilings of the US war on Iraq, but imagine if the super-power is China or Iran I guess the women here are forced to wear veils or the lesser of the two gender.
And your subject “democracy (in Malaysia)- dead or alive?”, I am wondering has it ever started?
December 11th, 2007 on 5:20 pm
Luce,
Though your cartoon depicts the Yanks’ oppression under teh guise of democracy, it is appropriate for both (the current) US and Malaysian govt. Both lie, oppress for power and control so that they may loot the public coffers, whether that be national oil or the contracts for projects, etc.
December 11th, 2007 on 7:38 pm
Ktemoc, your own country’s gomen loots its own resources and sell you National Paranoia and Apartheid – all under the double-speak of ‘National Security’ for 50 years. This is more immediate and pertinent than what the US is doing. Whaddya know, the US spoke out against this state of repression before anyone else has done. Not sure Steven Gan will give due credit though.
December 11th, 2007 on 7:38 pm
No matter what he says, actions always speak louder than words. He can preach to the whole world that our country is democratic, blah, blah, blah but what happened to BERSIH, HINDRAF and now the lawyers, democracy is truly dead. The only thing left is a wooden casket and a 6-ft deep hole to put it in.
December 11th, 2007 on 9:25 pm
hmm.. what is going on with Pak Lah? Nyanyuk?
December 12th, 2007 on 2:09 am
mave
yeah RIP democracy.
fred
glad you like the cartoon. though this cartoon is as ktemoc pointed out depict the yanks, it sort of tells on our gomen too, don’t you think so? people try to gather peacefully in the name of democracy but the gomen attacked them with tear gas and chemical water – same thing isn’t it?
walski
yes i heard something of that survey too. so you are saying democracy is still alive but going to die soon?
harrison
lulu? you mistaken me for lulu in ‘whatalulu’ blog. i’m not that famous lulu. i’m lucia.
hmm… yeah is there ever democracy in our UMNO controlled gomen at the start, i wonder too.
wits
tsk tsk, do you want me to come in to say again that you are very pro-USA? aiya, that was what ktemoc stated – it applied to both country, so he meant malaysia too lah… but you just have to say something good of USA.
billy
you are right. he can talk all he want but we know better.
edwin
yalah. dah tua… sikit nyanyuk i guess.